I have kept a notebook, on and off, for most of my adult life. For a long time I did it badly. Not because I wrote too little, but because I tried too hard.
The tidy years
My early notebooks were beautiful and almost useless. I bought good paper. I wrote in my best handwriting. I left a margin. If I made a mistake, I tore out the page and started again, which meant that a lot of what I thought never made it in at all.
I was writing for an imagined reader, someone who would one day open the book and admire it. The problem is that this reader does not exist. The only person who reads my notebooks is me, usually in a hurry, looking for something I half remember.
A notebook is not a record of what happened. It is a record of what I noticed, which is smaller and more honest.
What goes in now
Somewhere along the way I gave up on neatness. Now the notebook is a working object. It goes in my bag, gets rained on, and fills up with whatever the day hands me:
- Lines from books, with page numbers, so I can find them again.
- Overheard sentences from buses and tea stalls.
- Prices, directions, phone numbers, and the name of a good restaurant.
- Half-ideas for essays, most of which will never become anything.
- Small drawings, badly done, of things I want to remember the shape of.
Nothing is crossed out cleanly. Nothing is in order. A grocery list sits next to a line of poetry, and both are equally true about that afternoon.
Rereading
The real value of a notebook, I have found, is not in the writing but in the rereading. Every few months I sit down with an old one and a cup of tea and go through it slowly.
Most of it is dull. Some of it is baffling. I find notes like "the green door, ask about it", with no idea which door or whom I meant to ask. But every so often there is a line that brings a whole day back: the smell of a train station, a conversation with a stranger, a thought I had forgotten I ever had.
A notebook is not a record of what happened. It is a record of what I noticed, which is smaller and more honest. Over time, it shows me what I pay attention to, and sometimes what I keep missing.
Why paper
I have tried keeping notes on my phone. It works for lists and fails for everything else. On a screen, I edit as I go, and the note comes out polished and dead. On paper, I cannot go back and fix things, so the first version stays, with all its mistakes and its odd, accidental life.
There is also the matter of attention. A phone is always offering me something else. A notebook offers nothing but the page, which is exactly the point.
A small recommendation
If you want to start, buy a cheap notebook, one you will not be afraid to ruin. Carry it everywhere for a month. Write in it badly. Then, at the end of the month, read it back with a cup of tea, and see what you find.




